Chile Blog | Press | Praise | Living in Chile

Sunday, January 06, 2008

Chile's eGovernment to Run on Microsoft

Read me in the Washington Post, about the Microsoft deal that pissed everybody off. In September, Digital Liberation member Cristian Sepulveda pointed out that Chileans personal data harvested from the Civil Registry and put on Microsoft's servers could subject Chileans to gringo surveillance, based on a clause in the USA Patriot Act. My response to Cristian:

What do you have to hide?

But despite having such a great pasture for my 177 words to prance around in, there are many points I didn't manage to cover. I haven't had coffee yet so I can only remember one semi-clearly:

1. Chile is the first national client of Microsoft. Luis Ramirez, one of the Chilean bloggers who I emailed, points out that when he talked to the National Strategy Manager for Microsoft in Chile the latter said he thought this was the first time Microsoft Chile was doing Digital Address at a countrywide level. The fascinating conclusion to be drawn is that once again, Chile is an experiment country. Like democratic Marxism, neoliberalism - Chile could be the pilot for e-governments run by corporations, at a time when many countries are going open source.

Also, a lot of people frame this as Chile's government selling out its citizens and handing over 16 million new clients to Microsoft.

Here's a summary of many other peoples' hard work that I pilfered for personal glory:

T-Dog gives a great fantastic English language summary of the Chile Microsoft deal story.

Truth Happens noticed.

Sharpshooter was the original bitcher: The Day that Chile Sold Itself to Microsoft [Spanish]

Devil in the Details turns it into an interrogative: Is the Goverment of Chile Selling us to Microsoft? [Spanish]

Here's a classic example of we-know-what's best for you Chilean elitism [Spanish] which I thoroughly enjoyed but can't say I sourced it.
 

5 Comments:

At 2:24 PM, OpenID eldiabloenlosdetalles.net said...

I wrote a follow-up article criticizing Osorio's article [1]. Interestingly, he apologized for it [2]. I'm still waiting for a correction from 'Que Pasa' ;)

Cheers,
Carlos


[1] http://eldiabloenlosdetalles.net/2007/08/05/que-pasa-y-el-acuerdo-marco/

[2] http://eldiabloenlosdetalles.net/2007/08/05/que-pasa-y-el-acuerdo-marco/#comment-12690

 
At 3:21 PM, Blogger Chile Liberal said...

My comment is actually a question for you: how wour YOU feel if any governmment (your own or foreign) has access to your details?

That's my concern. I fear the chilean government (EFE, Transantiago, Chiledeportes) may have access to my private information. Let alone the US government.

What about privacy?

I have nothing to hide. It doesn't mean I want others to potentially be able to identify who I am, where I am, what I do, etc. Furthermore, this is about gathering information of lots of citizens (and information can be sorted, organised, analysed and then used).

On the other hand, the Liberación Digital crowd seem to be the nerdy-geeky-techy brigade who have aversion against Microsoft.

On top of that, the way the minister handled this important matter was terrible.

 
At 3:30 PM, Anonymous chuck goolsbee said...

Bah... Microsoft can not even sell their "new & improved" Vista, and people are begging to go back to XP. They can't even keep their X-Box live service... well.. LIVE and face lawsuits because of downtime.

Anyone who fears huge doings of corporate evil is basing their assumptions upon very shaky logic, namely that said corporation can actually operate in a competent fashion!

Based on Microsoft's track record, so long as you aren't selling a competing software package, you are pretty safe from their "evil."

--chuck

 
At 6:34 PM, Anonymous Chileno said...

@Devil in the Details

That is interesting. Thanks!

@Chile Liberal:

My comment about 'what's Cristian got to hide' was a joke. Anyway I agree with you about the whole issue of privacy, it's not about hiding anything it's about, well, privacy.

Also need to rebut another point: From what their members tell me, it's not that Liberación Digital is against Microsoft in particular, but rather any corporation doing what Microsoft has done. According to the interviews and stuff you can find online, their reaction would have been the same had it been Yahoo, Google, Oracle, whatever. (Although necessarily their reaction takes on the specific policies of MS because that's who's in the mix).

@Chuck:

Go back to WaPo and read that I wrote:

The netroots are still fighting what they see as a trend toward a dysfunctional and even Orwellian e-government. Worried that Microsoft products won't work with commonly used free software, some Chilean netizens banded together to form Digital Liberation, an online movement against the agreement.

As you can see, "Orwellian" is the second modifier, but also given due treatment is dysfunctional in other words the lack of interoperability with open source software. Due to space limitations etc we had to cut one of the most interesting - to me - slogans of Digital Liberation, warning against a:

Technological Transantiago.

If you don't know, Transantiago is the poorly planned and much-reviled public transit system that's got pretty much everyone up in arms. Pile on your observations about MS products as more fuel for the fire. So Digital Liberation thanks you, I'm sure :-)

 
At 9:31 PM, Blogger Missy A said...

Always can count on Sherman to deliver his audience a solid journalist piece; aking to those old-school journalism practices favored in the 1940's.

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home


Download Skype, Call Chile!

Apple Store

ComFi Phone Cards